Each year, the selection changes, but the flavor profile stays the same: fruity, chocolatey, spicy, and something with peanut butter.

In other words, a little something for everyone.

  • Spiced Molasses Cookies

    Soft, lightly spiced molasses cookie that is rolled in sugar before baking

    Contains: gluten, dairy

    Link to original recipe

  • Andes Mint Cookies

    Brownie base with an Andes mint swirled into the top of the cookie. We love to eat these frozen!

    Contains: gluten, dairy

    Link to original recipe

  • Peanut Butter Cookie Cups

    Soft peanut butter cookie cups with a melty mini Reeses cup in the middle

    Contains: gluten, dairy

    Link to original recipe

  • Cranberry Curd Bars

    Buttery shortbread crust topped with homemade creamy cranberry curd

    Contains: gluten, dairy

    Link to original recipe

  • Chocolate Dipped Orange Shortbread Penguin Cookies

    We smushed two recipes together to get this one: tangy orange shortbread cookies that are decorated to look like pudgy little penguins

    Contains: gluten, dairy

    Link to original cookie recipe